The Star-News


Embarrassed by an attorney's actions

Sat, Mar 23 2013 12:00 PM Posted By: M. Kevin O’neill

Attn.: Dan Shinoff

Having read your two letters of February 24, 2013 to BOC Chairman Marinovich, I am both embarrassed for and disappointed in your firm. You were either duped or compliant in the Superintendent's heavy handed attempts to silence any criticism from the BOC. The first letter makes it clear that you had no factual knowledge of the alleged incident and were instructed to send a “slap” letter. The follow up letter was a lame attempt to regroup. I find it ironic that you quote Board policy when the present Board and Superintendent recognize their policy primarily in the breech.

Allow me to provide context to the events of that evening. First and foremost, no one from our group asked to have a representative from the District come to us and extoll the virtues of the IPad program. What was asked for at the previous meeting and expected at this meeting was the written rationale of the District for the expenditure of the Bond funds on IPads. I made a motion that passed unanimously asking for this information, specifically the Board’s rational and not an attorney’s opinion. We received an e-mail from Mr. Calhoun stating that Ms. Castilleja would attend the meeting to “explain” the IPad program. I replied that Maria was fine but we expected the written rational that was requested.

The issue of the use of Bond funds for the purchase of IPads falls well within the BOC’s purview as does the effectiveness of the program since funds have already been used. Ms. Castilleja expertise is in the area of curriculum, and when quizzed on the useful life, maintenance, programing and mechanism to evaluate the effectiveness of the program in general and the IPads specifically, she answered that she was not part of the early decisions or that we would have to direct our questions to another department i.e. Finance, IT, Purchasing, etc. Our Chairman redirected when she went into her spiel about curriculum advantages of IPad use, something near and dear to her heart, but not germane to our area of concern.

More than one committee member expressed frustration with a seemingly headless program with no mechanism in place to judge its effectiveness. She was also told more than once that our criticism was not aimed at her and that she should not take it personally. Since she was sent to us to represent the District as their PMK, it only follows that she would be the one to hear our misgivings and frustration with the program in order to convey that to the Superintendent and the Board. Ms. Castilleja was hit with hard pointed questions for which she had no answers. Did we vent our frustrations? Yes. Was she treated disrespectfully or personally singled out? No, in fact, Chairman Marinovich’s comments were less aggressive than several CBOC members, why weren’t they sent letters as well?

The Prop “O” BOC is an independent oversight body that does not serve at the Board’s pleasure and certainly is not subservient to the Superintendent. The sooner the Superintendent realizes that this “group of cats” will not be herded and that we have claws, the sooner we can establish an effective working relationship.

Happily for us, the meeting was taped and there was at least one member of the broadcast media present during the alleged incivility. Ms. Castilleja may have a grievance but it is with those that sent her to us, ignorant of the information we requested, not with the BOC. Having said that, I can be gruff and do not suffer the fool well, so please give me any words or phrases in context that you and your client feel lacked civility so that we can learn from this. I know that I can speak for my fellow committee members when I say that it is not our intent to cause pain in a fellow human being. Should I not hear from you with examples within five days, I will accept that your letter was a misunderstanding of the circumstances.

Perception becomes reality and this episode smacks of a ham handed attempt to stifle and limit this group in the performance of our mandate.

O’Neil is a member of the Sweetwater Union High School District Citizens Bond Oversight Committee.

 


© 2009 The Star-News